Thursday, 18 June 2009

The battle of Conway Hall

Dear reader, our blog has moved to a new address.

Do come on over (and change your bookmarks accordingly): rationalist.org.uk

You may have read in today's papers about last night's aborted debate on Sharia law at London's Conway Hall, which the Guardian report as having in fact been an attempt to relaunch the extreme Islamist group Al-Muhajiroun, which disbanded back in 2004. What you may not have realised about this story is that the venue in which it occurred, Conway Hall, is in fact the historic home of British secularism, humanism and free thought – it's where we have our AGMs, and it's where the BHA hold their annual lectures and big events.

So this morning we tracked down Giles Enders, chair of the South Place Ethical Society, which owns the hall, to hear the full story of what happened there last night. Here's what we learnt – SPES had received a booking from a woman named Sami Khan, who was representing an organisation called the Global Issues Society. Khan booked the main hall for a debate on Sharia Law v British Law, which Enders understood would pit hardline Muslims against those of a more liberal persuasion. As people began arriving for the event, Enders says it became apparent that the hardliners had turned up, but not the liberals. We now know these "hardliners" to have been the would-be members of a reformed Al-Muhajiroun, led by controversial cleric Anjem Choudary. (As it happens, Choudary's "liberal" debate opponent was to be Douglas Murray, who runs the hardly-liberal, somewhat right-wing Centre for Social Cohesion - more on him later.)

Choudary and his supporters arrived at Conway Hall complete with their very own team of bouncers, who they placed on the doors and at the bottom of the stairs which lead to the main hall's gallery. It turns out their purpose was to enforce a Sharia-style system of gender segregation in the home of Britsih free thought, with the downstairs part of the whole reserved for men, and women confined to the gallery. The first Enders knew about this was when members of the Central London Humanist group also began arriving at the hall for their own meeting, which was due to take place in Conway Hall's library. But as that is upstairs, male members of the group were being refused access by Choudary's heavies. There were also female members of the press being refused entry to the main hall. At this point Enders intervened and attempted to explain that the Global Issues Society had booked the event as an "open meeting" and, besides, gender segregation would not be accepted at Conway Hall. At this point, it seems appropriate to recount what Enders told us earlier:
"These thuggish bouncers wouldn’t allow anyone in, so I said we would call the police. But the police took forever to come, so in the end I had to send our maintenance man across to the police station to get them. It became extremely aggressive in the foyer – somebody got hurt and was bleeding. I said to the bouncers that I run this bloody hall and what I say goes and they pushed me away. They wouldn’t even allow me in the hall, so I went round the side way and got on the stage, and made an announcement through the mic that the meeting was not to take place. After I said this I stood on the stage with all the chanting mob screaming at me in Arabic, and pointing fingers like guns at me. Then they then cut the mic I was using, as one of their people was operating the sound control box. Then the main speaker [Choudary] got hold of a radio mic and started shouting in Arabic. So I grappled that off him, and then I sat on the stage."
With the meeting cut short, the arguments spilled out on to the square outside the hall. Around 30-40 police turned up as, at this point, did Douglas Murray who, says Enders, "barged his way into the main hall. I asked him to leave, as I’d already thrown out the opposition. I had to call in a couple of police to make him leave."

So the big question is why a controversial Islamist group, whose stated aim is to turn Britain into an Islamic state governed by Sharia law, was allowed to attempt its relaunch in the centre of British humanism and free thought? In addition to the fact that SPES were led to believe the event would be a two-sided debate on Sharia law, the answer is simple. Conway Hall is run according to principles of free thought and free speech – indeed Enders describes as one of "the last homes of free speech in this country". As he told us, recent groups meeting at Conway Hall have included some supporters of the North Korean regime, a Stalinist meet-up group and, most recently, "a kinky group of Devil worshippers":
"As long as there is no trouble, and people pay, we don't interfere with them. But what we do interfere with is when something is advertised as an open meeting and then they want segregation. There must be open access – we can't have race discrimination or sex discrimination. This is the law of the land."
Choudary and his followers crossed that line, so Enders wrestled the mic from his hands and ended the meeting. We salute Giles "The End" Enders, the Hardman of Humanism.

14 comments:

Rob Gould said...

I'm sorry, but I'm sitting here mouth agape going through the story in the head. Absolutely unbelievable.

James said...

Wow. What an amazing story - can't believe I didn't manage to make it along (to the Humanists group, not the hardcore Muslims group!).

What makes it more amazing is that PETER TATCHELL, the famous human rights campaigner was there to talk to the humanists. I'd love to hear what he made of it all.

Udo Schuklenk's Ethx Blog said...

wow, hectic stuff, good on you Giles!

timbearcub said...

Good work! Amazing that they would treat the manager of the hall that way, though. Generally you don't mess with the person in control of the space and respect their wishes...nor treat others who are unrelated to the event like that.

And I very much doubt Peter Tatchell would have done anything.

Not enough cameras, members of the press and/or mirrors :-P

Pharkie said...

Brilliant work Giles!

SilverTiger said...

Yes, I think Giles Enders acted admirably and courageously.

Robin said...

As someone who attended this event, I wanted to clear up the factually incorrect interpretation of events referred to by Giles Enders. He says that Douglas Murray "barged his way into the main hall", with Enders having to "call in a couple of police to make him leave."

As security and independent witnesses will confirm, this is an utter fabrication. Murray most certainly did not 'barge his way' into the hall, but walked in through the front entrance. He was instructed by the police as well as his sadly necessary security detail to stay inside the hall for safety reasons until an estimation could be made of the volatile security situation outside. He then left of his own accord. The idea that the police had to make him leave is a quite outrageous attempt to conflate the security advice that Murray acted upon with the provocative and violent behaviour of the al-Muhajiroun thugs who were threatening him.

skepticat said...

Great piece. I was there and witnessed some of it. I've blogged about it here:

http://skepticat.wordpress.com/2009/06/18/loony-islamists-mistake-humanist-centre-for-mosque/

Blue Collar Todd said...

Liberals need to wake up to the fact that these Muslims are using them to advance Sharia Law. As soon as they are able to enforce it then they will come after you and intimidate you like at Conway Hall.

Michael Kingsford Gray said...

Onya mate for not losing your 'bottle'! :)

These people are mentally disturbed, having been infected by a dangerous meme. :(

kevin said...

Giles Enders. Who?
The guy who runs the Centre for Social Cohesion. Who?
The guy who wrote the neo concervative book. Who?
Douglas Murray. Who?
THE TIT WHO SAID BAN ALL LIBERALS FROM VOTING....................Who?

Tom A said...

kevin, you probably want to educate yourself mate, you're making yourself sound like a moron

kevin said...

Tom A

no one like to a run by halfwit and moron

sicne I dismay about why the far- left moron like Object. who like to ban everything to do with sex. not helping the women in the iran who try get free from the the hell hole.

if you probably want me to educate. here some.

one

Charlie Brooker

or two

Richard Dawkins


keep on the ball. Douglas Murray you the best hard man for the humanists and Secular and atheist. to take al-Muhajiroun thugs down.

Anonymous said...

Giles Enders: you're my hero